• boost authenticity
  • increase conversions
  • customer reviews,
  • build trust,

Aiming For The Sixth Star: Your How-to Guide On Winning Customer Reviews

Read More
All Posts

Aiming For The Sixth Star: Your How-to Guide On Winning Customer Reviews

Sometimes products seem to be less glorious than they deserve to be, just because they aren’t backed by customer reviews. Reviews have the power to shape opinions within seconds. 90% of customers say buying decisions are influenced by online reviews! Read on and decide for yourself if reviews is something that needs to be a part of your plan of taking your online store to the next level.

The first ever steel wire suspended bridge, that connects Manhattan to Brooklyn was built in 14 years. But when it did get ready, people were skeptical. They had never seen anything like this before! As it was just held by suspended cables, they were scared that the bridge would collapse.

To aggravate that thought, a week later, a woman slipped and fell on the wooden steps before the bridge. And everyone flipped! There was a lot of screaming, a lot of running and everyone was panic-stricken. Everyone thought the bridge was giving up, and there was a mad rush towards the exit. A stampede took place which led to 12 deaths and 35 people were injured.

After this incident, the government could see the 15.5 million dollars, that was spent in the construction of the bridge go down the drain. It had to be proven that the bridge was so strong that it was capable of withstanding a lot of weight. It was time for ‘show and tell’. To gain their trust, the Govt decided to go beyond the ordinary and do something completely out of the way. Just before the 1st anniversary of the bridge, they roped in PT Barnum (owner of Barnum & Bailey circus) to prove that the suspension bridge was as sturdy as they had claimed.

So here is what Barnum did - he paraded 21 elephants to cross the bridge back and forth! It was a sight to behold! People were stunned. They got their proof and things got back to normal soon after. This is how we humans operate. Influence drives change.

As Cialdini said, that change generated from influence could swing both ways; it could spike up one's growth, by guiding them to the right direction and creating conditions for positive changes. On the other hand, it could be used rather lethargically, which might attract conflict and resentment. Trust needs to be gained, for people to get inspired and perform the desired action.

E-commerce is no different. When shopping, users are subconsciously accumulating trust points. When users are browsing through your catalogue, they are looking for signals that could help them trust your products and your brand. We have spoken about how brand story is critical for scoring trust with users.

Don’t just tell. Show them.

Trust is often gained by unusual ways. 

millennials review statStat Source

Robert Cialdini in his book Psychology of Persuasion beautifully explains how people rely on safety in numbers. More the people buying a particular product, more the people believe in its credibility. People are hungry for validation; once they realize that others are appreciating a product, it persuades them to make a purchase.

Product reviews impact your bottom line

88% of consumers trust online customer reviews as much as personal recommendations! Someone the user has no previous contact whatsoever has the power to influence them to click on the buy button! Users consider products reviews to be extremely critical in their decision-making process. Higher the customer reviews (positive over negative), higher the sales. People put their faith in the number of customer reviews a product has before buying it.

review statsSource

Everything on the product page is all talk until someone who has bought the product puts down their thoughts. Packaging and presentation, both have a lasting impact on sales. The way you present your product is what matters at the end of the day and not just the product in itself. Unfair? You bet. But you can’t blame the users; what they see is what they believe. The best they can do is look at the product images and read the product descriptions. But to get the real sense of how valuable the product is, they will need unbiased opinions of other buyers and their experience with the product. This is where product reviews are mission critical.


product review stat


Why are customer reviews critical?

Reviews are important for varied reasons. While it usually associated with building trust, it is actually just the tip of the iceberg. Here is why customer reviews are more than just customer’s feedback-

Seal of assurance

Customer reviews build credibility and nudge users to make a purchase. It assures the users that they can rely on you for delivering the product. This especially helps if you are a new store. It shows that people are purchasing from your store and find it worth the buy.

review statsSource

Gives an exact idea about the product

Even if you provide a size chart, users usually think twice before they buy. A review with a ‘raw image’ shows exactly how the product looks like, the size of the product, the precise color of the product etc.

customer review example sheen


Helps You Acquire More Users and Rank higher in search

Believe it or not, customer reviews help you nail the right keywords. When customers write reviews, they make use of common keywords, words that people actually search for. The long tail keywords are taken care of here. Moreover, as customer reviews keep getting added, the page keeps getting updated. Due to the regular updation, the page starts ranking higher in a search.

yotpo review impacts seo

Yotpo conducted a survey where they observed the boost in the SEO once the customer reviews were added. By month 9 they saw a drastic hike in organic traffic.

Increases conversion rate

Jabra, an online store that sells headphones and speakers was facing a lot of drop-offs from the product page. It was when they conducted a survey with their users did they realize that the users were not sure about the product; if it was comfortable, if it would fit them right and so on. To build trust, Jabra went ahead and reached out to customers for product reviews. This change helped them in increasing the sales by 76.92%.

Customer reviews encourages users to make a purchase. It is seen that products with 100 or more customer reviews experience a 37% lift in conversions! Every review counts. More the number of positive reviews, higher are the chances of increasing sales.

Good source of feedback

Customer reviews are not only beneficial for the users but also for the merchants. It is an opportunity to know your product from a different pair of eyes. It helps you improve your products and provide users with a better experience.

Quote on customer review

The art of asking for customer reviews

Not everyone who buys from your store will write a review unless asked. After all, customers don't buy products to write reviews. Once the product is delivered, the customer would use the product and might not go back to your store to write how they feel about the product. That's why you need to ASK your customers to write a review.

customer review

Identify customers who are likely to review your product

While you can ask every customer who buys from you, you can follow up with specific customers, who have higher chances of taking out time to write a review. Segmentation is also beneficial, especially when you are giving out incentives for writing customer reviews. Target customers according to-

  • Shopping behavior

Reach out to customers who have purchased more than once. They are more likely to write a review as they like your products and have laid their trust upon you by purchasing a second product.

  • Amount of purchase

The amount they have spent on your store also indicates that they are interested in your store. High-end products especially need to be backed by customer reviews to lure users into buying it. Reviews from customers who have made a big purchase can be valuable. It has been observed that customers don’t hesitate to make a big purchase when the product is backed with plenty of reviews.

Incentivize if required

Even if you nudge them to leave a review, users need not take out time for it. To grab their attention, you need to lure them with an incentive. On an average 18.5% more customers would write reviews if you incentivize. It could be a coupon code that they can avail the next time they make a purchase, it could be shopping points, you can cut delivery charges for their next purchase.

Pampers, with their rewards programme, offers different incentives for writing a review. They now have thousands of customer reviews vouching for them. Wish.com is another store that offers incentives for writing reviews. They give bonus points, for uploading a photo or a video of the purchase they made.

Build social proof with User Generated Content

Users trust normal images over glossy product images when it comes to making a purchasing decision. It also projects how the product looks on different people, helping users get an idea about the product. 55% of customers trust User Generated Content over other forms of marketing.



Reviews on social media

68% of customers go to social networking sites to read product reviews. The best part about customer reviews on social is that, their followers get to see it, luring them to make a purchase from your store. To leverage this, you could also encourage them to share their review on their social profiles for brownie points.


Send them a thank you gift with their order

Showing some extra love goes a long way. When you make them happy, the reciprocatory nature of humans gets into action. The users would then want to show their appreciation. Reach out to them when they are willing to pour their heart out. Higher are the chances that they would write a review when they are delighted.

personal note for reviews

Best time to ask for a review

Customers should be approached for a review as soon as the product is delivered and then get back to them within a few hours if they have not responded. By then they would have explored the product and can complement the review with the image/ video of the product. Make sure that you ask for a review when it is fresh in their mind.

customer review quote

Reaching out to your customers

The user engages on your product page- Check. User buys a product - Check. The product gets delivered - Check. Now what? You need to reach out to them! By now, they ideally should have subscribed to your web push notifications and/or email. This helps you reach out to specific users who have made a purchase and request them to give a review.

Build your marketing list and engage with users from day zero. Try Web Push Notifications for Free!

While you are at it, you could also ask them close-ended questions like “Would you buy this product again?”,  “Would you recommend this product to a friend?”. You could use this data and boost the confidence of the user and influence them into purchasing.

customer reviews


Grab the opportunity to cross-sell products as well. Show them what product they need to buy to complement their purchase. More options for them which means more sales for you. Here, you get an opportunity to hit two birds with one stone.

“The most valuable way to reach new potential customers is through your current customers”-  Andres Maldonado, Co-founder Biciclasica. 

Stand out with Google Reviews

Google Star Ratings

Google Customer Reviews allows sellers to collect feedback from customers for free. This helps in making your store stand out and increases credibility. This review refers to the experience your customer has on your website as a whole, like the support you provide, the way you handle returns etc.

You can head here to know how you can get started with Google Customer reviews.

Once you set up Google Customer Reviews, you can choose where you want the reviews to appear -

Google Customer review opt-in

This appears to all customers who check out. Users who opt-in to receive an email, will be sent an email asking them to review the experience of your store.

Google Review Badge

You can place this anywhere on your site to show your seller rating score. You could also place it on the product pages to build authenticity. The review badge gives users an idea of what other people think of your store.

Google Customer review survey

This is a brief questionnaire that people answer on basis of the experience on your website. You can know more about these surveys and how you can start with it, in this whitepaper.

Google Seller Rating on Google Text and Display Ads

Google Seller Rating shows both information and the ratings your store has got, influencing users to click on your website. Though the seller rating is free, once the users click on your ad, the usual prices will be applicable.

Criteria for seller ratings to be shown on ads

  • 150 seller reviews in the span of 12 months
  • Seller needs to receive a minimum of 3.5 stars  

Seller rating on text ads can boost the Click Through Rate up to 10%

Product Review Stars

Here the ratings pertain to a particular product rather than the experience a user has with the entire store. Imagine someone searches for shoes and your store shows up along with the Ad of your competitor store. While the user can click on either of the stores, the higher chances are that they would click on the store which has ratings on them.


Criteria for Product Ratings to be shown in search results

  • A product must have a minimum of 3 customer reviews
  • The entire website must have at least 50 customer reviews when combined

Review platforms to leverage from

The ratings are based on a number of sources. One of the sources they take feedback is from independent review websites. Google has given license to 3rd party review aggregators. You can have a look at the entire list here. But here are the platforms we recommend-

Starts from $0
Includes 50 million monthly orders


Shopper Approved
Starts from $199
Discounted pricing available for Small businesses (less than 200 orders per month)

Trustpilot_brandmark_gr-blk_RGB-320x132pxTrust Pilot

Starts from 0$
Includes 100 invitations per month


Verified Reviews
Starts from $99
Includes 400 orders per month


Analyzing customer reviews and how to handle negative ones

Negative customer reviews do not mean that your store is bad or your dream to make more sales is crashing down. The thing is, it would be an overestimation of your think you will always receive 5 stars. Plus, when you start receiving customer reviews, you can’t expect all the reviews to be positive. Consider every review to be a constructive feedback.

"When you receive a negative review, reach out to them and provide the best solution as soon as possible. We call the customers directly or drop an email and try to resolve the issues that the customer faced."

- Kislay P,  Marketing Manager, CanadaPetCare

Here is why you need to embrace negative reviews-

They add a dash of authenticity

Users might think there is something fishy if your customers are just singing the praises of your product. Negative reviews also show that the customer reviews aren’t fake or manipulated. So a bad review once in a while is actually good for you. It shows that you are not hiding anything to make to seem all goody good.

stats on negative reviews

Provides a realistic view of a product

Merchants sometimes create an unrealistic picture of a product, which might create an unpleasant experience for a customer. Negative reviews might also give users a possibility of the product not meeting the expectation. While the chances are more than a lot of positive customer reviews would overpower the negative one while taking a purchasing decision.

Feedback for you

Like mentioned earlier in the article, it’s an opportunity for you to know what you might be missing and a chance for you to improve.

Amazon’s Buy Box lists different sellers according to the seller reviews. But when a user is searching for a product, seller reviews does not play a role in product discoverability. Amazon’s SERP is product review centric. The volume of the feedback  plays a major in ranking each store on the seller page. To really rank in the buy box, just feedback is not enough; fulfillment and landed price needs to be taken into consideration as well.

Hygiene checks

Make it mobile friendly - If you are still not optimized for mobile, it is high time you do so because 56% of customer reviews come from mobile

Don't include many steps - The review process should be simple. Users might not dedicate time to fill open-ended questions. Keep it short and simple.

Make CTA’s evident on the site - When the customers revisit the website, make sure that the ‘Write a review’ CTA is prominently visible.

Respond to customer reviews even if they are not positive - Just because you receive a negative review, it does not mean that you don't answer them. In fact, negative customer reviews are the ones you should definitely not ignore. Replying to these customers gives you an opportunity to build a better bond.

Customer reviews have the power to win new customers. They are a like a trophy you can flaunt. What you need to make sure that you need to engage with the users before they make a purchase and nurture them once they buy a product. Customer reviews can do wonders to your bottom of the funnel. So start reaching out to your customers for reviews and let those sales pour in!           

Reach out to your customers for reviews and increase sales with Web Push Notifications. Get started for Free!        


Pravya Pravin
Pravya Pravin
Pravya Pravin is a Product Marketer at iZooto. An artist who paints not only with words, but also on canvas. She loves exploring places less traveled and wishes to go on a bike trip to the highest motorable road.

Related Posts

Segmentation 101 - Moving Beyond Flat Personas To Retarget Better

In this age of personalized marketing, turning a blind eye towards seg[...]

Now Live: Push Notifications on Opera and Edge

Opera and Edge together constitute to about 5% of browser share global[...]

Now Live: A Fresh Way to Work With Your Subscription Prompt

Web push notification is a permission-based medium and you can use Sub[...]